We open with the clear winner on the pool itself — if you want a real resort pool to swim in, Four Seasons at West Lake has both a heated indoor pool and an outdoor garden pool, the only outdoor lakeside pool on this list, scoring 9.6/10 from over 698 real reviews, the highest here. It's a 17-acre Jiangnan garden resort with interconnected lily ponds that feels like a Zen getaway in the middle of the city, and with only 78 rooms it stays quiet and private. The outdoor pool is wrapped in greenery and ponds, with the feel of West Lake all around as you swim. Guests praise the gorgeous gardens, the Four Seasons service and the breakfast. The honest caveat: it's on the west side of the lake near Lingyin Temple, with no metro at the door, so you take a taxi or hotel car into town, and the price is full luxury.
- ✓ 9.6/10 from 698 reviews — the top score on this list
- ✓ Both a heated indoor pool + an outdoor garden pool (the only outdoor one here)
- ✓ A 17-acre garden resort on the west shore of West Lake
- ✓ Just 78 rooms, quiet and private + a designer spa
- ✗ On the west shore with no metro at the door — taxi needed
- ✗ Full luxury pricing, from ¥4,000+
- ✗ Away from the city's shopping / night markets